underh20 wrote:I really don't understand the whole hot money issue. Can you elaborate?
I am a layman too. But Let's try to explain in simple words and specifically for China (otherwise, hot money is just volatile money moving very quickly in search of the best interest rates or best currencies rates).
For much better references, I advise you to read regularly the column of Michael Pettis here :
http://seekingalpha.com/article/100010- ... ousness-up
and here:
http://www.chinastakes.com/
Funny, because yesterday, there were 2 differents articles about hot money in chinastakes.com. The only advantage I found in reading M. Pettis is that being an academic, he has no any vested interest to tout anything. Besides, he gets often interesting "insider" infos through his former students who take positions in banks..etc.
Ok, basically, the definition of hot money for China is money which is entering (and now seems flowing out) the country not as FDI or as trade surplus. of course, this is very simplistic because in reality:
many inflows of hot money can be disguised as FDI; and as you can guess since august why the government is now checking so carefully all import export accounts, hot money can be also hidden in legitimate trade transactions.
For example, anecdotically, for the last 4 years, i have 5 big suppliers (one of them a large batteries maker in Suzhou) who ask me to pay all my purchases on their HK accounts.
Well, this is almost same as when my large north african customers pay me 35% of each shipment from Dubai to decrease the invoices amounts.
The inflow of foreign currencies has to be "sterilized" into RMB, therefore increasing the reserve growth (thus printing more RMB) which automatically will push inflation. But this is just the nice abstract economic theory
what many people suspect is that a very large amount of hot money is actually chinese money, but parked outside of China
As you surely know, Under, for chinese people with this kind of money, we dont need talk about the yearly limit of US$ 50,000. They have their ways (remember the small cigarettes shop in shenzen border passing billions of RMB to HK for the stock market, so the other way is true too)
The hot money started really to flow in China in 2005 when the RMB was de-pegged. At that time, people brought their money in China to bet on: RMB revaluation; property hot market; stock hot market.
There is another channel for the hot money, which the informal lending system (such as the Wenzhou underground banks that the China government has tried to "legalize" without much success in august) but I leave this aside for the moment.
Now, october 2008: the stock market is down 70% from october 2007; the real estate market starts to crack seriously, and it is going to be more serious soon because banks don't lend anymore as before.
and worse, there is a lot of talk inside the government circles to try to stop the RMB revaluation and maybe even reverse the movement to help the exporters who are going through hellish times
so, even if the figures of M. Pettis are not 100% accurate: in Q3, wth a trade surplus almost double of the Q1 one, the headline reserve growth is dropping steeply, and above all , the unexplained amount (mostly between trade surplus + FDI and reserve growth ) drops by half.
Of course, with China official data, we are never sure of the authenticty and accuracy, but I think it is pretty correct. ( if the unexplained amount passes from 30 billions to 14, with a much bigger trade surplus, it surely means that not only there is no new hot money coming in, but that it starts to move out)
A last word about "informal" banking: this is not new for me; I know tens of SME in zhejiang for example, who get financing for more than one year from wenzhou underground banks because regular banks are reluctant to loan, even more now that the export sector takes a hit (if you remember the Yiwu boss making socks who went into hiding and left a tab of 2 billions to the underground banks in july 2008, you will see what I mean).
But because now, the prospects of export sector are very grim, the property market will drop like stone, and the stock market will not recover , this hot money will flow out quickly.
In theory, it should be a good thing; problem is the crazy growth of the last 4 years was in very large part built on this a "lawless" money (same like Thailand in 1997).
This hot money leaving, plus definitely a reduction of FDI and even surely some foreign companies who will disinvest from China to bring back capital, possibly will bring serious liquidity pressure too in Chinese financial system.
Ouff I thought I would write just 10 lines...sorry for the long speech...Hope it is not too confused. If I have made some mistakes or inaccuracies feel free to correct me..but please dont flame me
