
palominocn wrote:chinese government's policy in real estate prevent the bubble from growing up.


rickettyrabbit wrote:palominocn wrote:chinese government's policy in real estate prevent the bubble from growing up.
Bubble? What bubble? There's no bubble is there?![]()
Properties in Shanghai are overvalued by 100 to 200% using fundamental analysis. For a typical Shanghai apartment, let's say 3 years old, the value is approximately double what makes sense. That should give you some idea about the extent of the bubble.
Some markets can remain in a bubble for a long time when investors are irrationally optimistic about future prices. That is the condition in Shanghai. Irrational optimism.
I'm guessing that Soros sees serious weakness in some of those real estate development companies, and wants to buy into them at bargain basement prices. If so, he's acting more like Warren Buffet than a short-seller.

palominocn wrote:rickettyrabbit wrote:palominocn wrote:chinese government's policy in real estate prevent the bubble from growing up.
Bubble? What bubble? There's no bubble is there?![]()
Properties in Shanghai are overvalued by 100 to 200% using fundamental analysis. For a typical Shanghai apartment, let's say 3 years old, the value is approximately double what makes sense. That should give you some idea about the extent of the bubble.
the bubble's burst still can't lead to the collapse of the whole economy, and chinese government have vented some hot airs out of the bubble.
rickettyrabbit wrote:Some markets can remain in a bubble for a long time when investors are irrationally optimistic about future prices. That is the condition in Shanghai. Irrational optimism.
I'm guessing that Soros sees serious weakness in some of those real estate development companies, and wants to buy into them at bargain basement prices. If so, he's acting more like Warren Buffet than a short-seller.
palominocn wrote:solos want to invent in developers instead of real estate? plausible. but i think he maybe just want to prolong the bubble or swell another bigger bubble, so can short china easily in the future.


Maybe you're right, and maybe you're wrong. You don't know that. Events like bubble collapses are too difficult to gauge ahead of time. Depending on what else happens because of it, it could hurt very badly.
Which banks do you think will fail if apartment prices drop by 50%? Do you have any idea? I don't think you've looked at any Chinese bank balance sheets lately.
I think he sees the weakness and wants to invest. As Buffet has said, the time to invest is when everyone is afraid and in despair. Maybe Soros is a little early. Palo's not afraid or in despair . . . yet.

palominocn wrote:Maybe you're right, and maybe you're wrong. You don't know that. Events like bubble collapses are too difficult to gauge ahead of time. Depending on what else happens because of it, it could hurt very badly.
Which banks do you think will fail if apartment prices drop by 50%? Do you have any idea? I don't think you've looked at any Chinese bank balance sheets lately.
as you have said it's diffcult to predict the time of burst, it's also difficult to measure the bigness of the bubble. i know there is a report saying chinese banks can't remain healthy if the price will drop by 50%, but the probability of the apartment price dropping by 50% is nearly zero. a newly developed residence area in shanghai was sold off in a week after the price was cut off by 20%. Soros feels uneasy that the bubble is still not too big to make the property market avalanche. so he wants to add some fuel to the market.
I think he sees the weakness and wants to invest. As Buffet has said, the time to invest is when everyone is afraid and in despair. Maybe Soros is a little early. Palo's not afraid or in despair . . . yet.
palominocn wrote:there is a chinese saying: dog can't change the habit of eating sh1t. i don't think Soros will change to invest in his 80's, his final purpose is to shortsale.





palominocn wrote:compare the property price of beijing with tokyo soeul taipai




DoReMe wrote:George Soros is well know currensies speculant, but finally he become nice guy and come to China for spreading goodness.
If i remember correctly, due "the Crysis" Cn Govt. helped property market with 500 Billions of dollars
what caused home prices was mostly doubled.
If Soros can add the same value - prices will triple (counting from 2008).
In result probaly will caused Bloody Revolution, good old Chinese revolution wich will
WIPE CHINA FROM THE WORLD MAP FOR ANOTHER 50 -100 YEARS.
America will kept own dominance.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
500 BILLIONS OF DOLLARS - is not that big price for THE DEAL, right, Soros ?


Ground Zero




Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests